Fostering a Culture of Belonging in the Hybrid Workplace

Authors: Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic and Katarina Berg

There is more to human existence than work; however, it is clear that if we are going to devote a third of our adult lives to our jobs, it is helpful to find them meaningful. The degree of meaning and purpose you derive from work may be the biggest difference between a job and a career, and psychological research has consistently shown that when employees feel that they belong to a team or organization—in the sense that it aligns with their values and enables them to express important aspects of their identity—they will not only tend to perform better but will also experience higher levels of engagement and well-being. In contrast, a lack of belonging will increase the risk of alienation, burnout, and underperformance.

Given this evidence, organizations need to foster belonging in their employees, and modern managers need to act as agents of meaning and purpose if they wish to retain their employees. That is in fact much harder than attracting new talent. This feeling of belonging has become challenged as we’ve shifted away from in-person interactions and found ourselves relying on video calls and screen activities to stay connected. HR and senior executives have encountered new demands when it comes to creating and sustaining a sense of real community, and they are realizing that new skill sets are needed.

It is not that leaders are disinterested in boosting a sense of belonging among their employees but rather that there isn’t a simple way to do it. This is especially true in an age of hybrid work, when organizations are not only trying to increase the flexibility of working arrangements but are also working on offering remote policies, which can decrease opportunities to “live and breathe” the culture in person. To be clear, culture does not go away when the office is a bit emptier, nor does it cease to evolve. However, as the experience of culture the way we have gotten used to defining it has become more diffused, elusive, and subjective, it’s harder for organizations to connect with people—and connect them to one another—through a homogeneous cultural experience. If work is something you do and not a place you come to, then maybe it is time to jettison the notion that culture sits within the four walls of the office. We can embrace the fact that we are all living in a gigantic experiment, where technology and what we used to call “the workplace” no longer have any limitations. We can instead focus on human needs and wants in order to stay healthy, productive, creative, social, and inspired.

Idea in Brief

• The Challenge

As organizations transition to hybrid work, fostering a sense of belonging among employees becomes increasingly complex. The physical separation and varied work environments can lead to feelings of isolation and disconnection.

• The Solution

Leaders can build a culture of belonging by implementing strategies that promote inclusivity and connection. This includes regular check-ins, virtual team-building activities, and opportunities for informal interactions. Providing equitable access to resources and ensuring transparent communication are key, as are encouraging employee participation in decision-making and recognizing people’s contributions.

• The Payoff

Building a culture of belonging in hybrid work can enhance employee satisfaction and performance.

To address this, organizations (and leaders) must navigate three major challenges:

1. Balancing the tension between a strong culture and effective diversity, inclusion, and belonging practices

To elevate the importance of diversity, companies need to harness an inclusive culture, where people feel valued and respected, and perhaps even recruited, for their differences. Spotify, where Katarina is the chief human resources officer, defines “diversity” as being invited to the party, “inclusion” as being asked to dance, and “belonging” as when they play your song. Sound simple? Perhaps, but when you want to dance with a broad range of personalities, and you want to cater to everyone’s unique preferences, you risk having no one come to your club.

People—whether at work or in any area of life—gravitate toward simple, clear-cut propositions, and just as nuanced rationality is unlikely to win you political elections (it requires people to be open-minded rather than tribal), a culture that tries to be everything to everyone could easily become interesting to very few. This is why “culture fit” is a popular approach to hiring and promoting talent—it is a lot easier than DIB. When you finally start to talk about the fact that diversity comes with a cost, things like hiring for culture add-on (ensuring that whoever joins adds something new to the team) rather than fit really come to life. Managers and employees have to understand and commit to this extra cost since its benefits will come much later. Diversity will initially slow you down, it will create misunderstandings, and when people come from different, inequitable backgrounds, opinions and worlds will collide. And how do you master the noble art of dealing with that?

2. Retaining the social element of work, even when people continue to work from home

Work is not just a vehicle for productivity, it’s also an opportunity to have meaningful connections with others, which can enhance our overall experience of life. This is the main reason why many people miss the office: the desire to regain some of the lost magic that makes work more human. Those who are eager—and able—to return to the office will probably experience a sense of belonging, or perhaps it is their very sense of belonging that propels them to return to the office. But what are employers going to do for those who can’t return, due to Covid-19 or related personal reasons? If, aside from personal circumstances and constraints, people decide to remain at home or continue to work in physical distance from others, how can we truly cater to their need for meaning and purpose, and ensure that they feel included in the next chapter of the company’s cultural evolution?

As INSEAD’s Gianpiero Petriglieri has pointed out, for all the talk of the future of work, the real reason we’ll go back to the office is a cocktail of 50% social pleasure and 50% social pressure. We want to see people, and we don’t want them not to see us. If he is right, then organizations should worry that they are not attracting people back to the office because the employees feel any true sense of belonging there but due to the more superficial and mundane reasons that workers want to catch up with colleagues and comply with management’s preferences (whether these are explicitly stated or not). How do you “set your children free,” trusting that they will be OK and will know that the family is always there to support and care for them? And when they feel lonely and miss the “third room”—the camaraderie and spontaneous socialization—how do you help them rekindle relationships, feel a stronger connection, and remain an active part of the cultural evolution?

In Spotify’s recent work-from-home employee survey, the biggest concern was indeed how to nurture a sense of belonging while being at home, which led the business to unpack what that means not just now but also in the future. It prompted discussions about what leaders need to keep doing, stop doing, and improve upon to promote a relevant sense of community and culture while people are distributed and in different circumstances. We are, above all, social beings and creatures of habit. But no matter how many virtual and digital social happenings we have added to our schedules, it doesn’t measure up to the real thing. People are longing for the connective tissue and social glue we once took for granted.

3. Having the courage to let the culture evolve

All cultures are the products of legacies—in particular the historical values of their leaders, or at least their impact. The temptation to cling to the past is always strong. But big, external changes force cultures to evolve. And when cultures survive—or even thrive—in the face of external changes, the temptation is to augment them. However, each crisis gives way to a new version of the world, and just because a system managed to survive an actual crisis doesn’t mean there is no need to change it. It’s like a heavy smoker, drinker, or overeater who is hospitalized from a heart attack and manages to survive—the answer going forward is not to smoke, drink, or eat even more but to change those habits. And changing habits involves replacing old practices with new ones rather than relishing the opportunity to go back to the past.

It is often said that we should learn from failure, and that it’s a lot harder to learn from success—because even when we are lucky, we are tempted to think we were just smart, which is the best way to do something dumb in the future. What is clear is that one cannot draw too many conclusions from surveys and close dialogue with employees during a pandemic, since people are living with fear, anger, and depression. As we emerge from the pandemic, we need to figure out how to create a sense of belonging and community within organizations, when the fear, anger, and depression are being replaced by choice, flexibility, and freedom.

Although nobody knows what the future will bring, we can expect a range of approaches to making hybrid work actually work. Perhaps the office will play more of a collaborative, creative, and innovative role, serving as a catalyst for stimulating in-person encounters and check-ins with colleagues to get our minimum dose of physical contact. The office may soon become our social and community node rather than the place you come to do your work. It most likely will be important for internal networking, especially for Gen C, or “Generation Covid,” the generation that will hit the job market after Gen Z. No matter what approach you choose, it is important to make it explicit, to ensure that people understand your rationale, and to have the humility and data-informed mindset to evaluate what works—and what doesn’t—and be ready to adjust accordingly.